... Folsom's ruling dismissed the charges without prejudice, which means prosecutors could restart the case, but the judge said the Marine Forces Central Command could not be involved if that happens. ...

... 'We are grateful for the judge's ruling today. He truly was the 'last sentinel' to guard against unlawful command influence,' said Richard Thompson, president of the law center. 'Tragically, our own government eliminated one of its most effective combat commanders. The insurgents are laughing in their caves.'

The defense attorneys noted that during the time period for which Chessani was charged, his superiors had praised his work:

'Leads Marines from front in every operation … Demonstrates moral courage every day … Always seeks advantage over complex, diverse insurgent enemy … A superb leader, who knows his men, knows the enemy, knows his business … Recommended selection for promotion to colonel.'

The charges were brought against Chessani and seven other Marines after U.S. Rep. John Murtha, D-Pa., publicly accused service members of being murderers. ...

... 'All the information I get, it comes from the commanders, it comes from people who know what they're talking about,' Murtha told reporters.

Murtha's statements, however, conflicted with investigative results from the military itself. An initial investigation by Army Col. G.A. Watt found 'there are no indications that (Coalition Forces) intentionally targeted, engaged and killed noncombatants.' Later, Army Maj. Gen. Aldon Bargewell found no coverup, the law firm said. ...